Superman/ Batman: Public Enemies DVD
// September 30th, 2009 // No Comments » // Comics, Movies, Review
This week brings us the release of Superman/ Batman: Public Enemies.
This one hour movie is based on the opening arc (of the same name) from Jeph Loeb’s Superman/ Batman ongoing series. Considering it’s been about 3 years since Loeb has done anything worth reading, it’s nice to be reminded that he used to be talented.
The premise of Public Enemies is that Lex Luthor becomes President and convinces the world that Superman is a killer, forcing him to go on the lamb. (I wonder why they call it that?) Oh, and there is a gigantic meteor about to destroy the Earth. So it’s like the Fugitive meets Armageddon with Capes. It’s actually much better than that sounds.
Sure, this isn’t exactly a Tennessee Williams play, but it’s fun. The point of Superman/ Batman was to give people what they want: the two-man Justice League. Because when you have Supes and Bats, what else do you need? Is Green Arrow really all that necessary? Public Enemies kind of proved he isn’t. Together, the boys take down a slew of villains, several heroes and yes, even a huge meteorite. (In the comics, it was made of kryptonite. Here its just a green rock.)
The movie is a pretty decent translation. It’s amazing how close Bruce Timm’s animation crew is to Ed McGuiness’ artwork. Had DC chosen to do the Supergirl storyline (sequentially, the next arc in the comic), it would have been extremely disappointing compared to Michael Turner’s (R.I.P.) pages. But it ends up a great match. Public Enemies is another great entry in Bruce Timm’s belt. Many of the voice actors from the so-called Dini-verse are here including the one true Batman, Kevin Conroy, and Tim Daly who played Superman in the 1990′s cartoon. But it is important to note that this story does not take place in Timm and Paul Dini’s animated universe (which is now considered to be one of the 52 Earths in the DCU). Despite the similarities, Public Enemies is meant to stand on it’s own.
That fact may be where the movie fails. Public Enemies is very entertaining, but it is an even mix of the comic and the cartoon series, and never manages to establish itself or stand on it’s own. There are a few key difference between the source material and the movie, but the scenes that are changed up only serve to abridge plot points Loeb created as part of an over-arching storyline. None of the new scenes are there to add any new facets to the story.
Also, it’s never clear what rating the producers are going for. There are some moments taken from the comic that are less than all ages. In particular, there’s a mention as to the enormous size of Power Girl’s breasts. But it isn’t stated directly. There’s also a key death that’s deleted and some drug usage. The story flirts with PG 13 material, but never goes all the way, making the attempt confusing. Fortunately, they left in the bizarre kiss between Luthor and “the Wall”. I would have been severely disappointed if that bit of insanity were left out.
Again, it’s still worth watching. DC has added another quality animated film to it’s roster. But I’m hoping that the next outing is less of a direct adaptation.
I’ll give Public Enemies a 7 out of 10.













